FAI: Prisoner’s death might have been avoided with hospital transfer
A 71-year-old prisoner who died at HMP Glenochil might have survived if he had been taken to hospital when paramedics first assessed him, a fatal accident inquiry has concluded.
Sheriff Robert More found that Joseph Glass should have been transferred after ambulance staff and an out-of-hours GP agreed he needed hospital care. In hospital, he would have received continuous cardiac monitoring and immediate access to resuscitation and defibrillation. The sheriff found that prompt defibrillation could have made the arrhythmia survivable.
Mr Glass died on 15 May 2021 from cardiomegaly, or enlargement of the heart, associated with ischaemic and valvular heart disease. The sheriff said a reasonable precaution could realistically have avoided his death and identified a defect in the Scottish Ambulance Service’s system of working that contributed to it.
Mr Glass had been sentenced to 11 years’ imprisonment, including a custodial term of eight years, at the High Court in Edinburgh on 19 September 2018. He would have qualified for parole on 20 December 2021, with his earliest release date set for 19 December 2025.
The inquiry heard that the ambulance service received a call at around 8:40pm on 14 May 2021 after Mr Glass became generally unwell and had difficulty speaking between breaths. Paramedics arrived within 20 minutes and assessed that he should go to hospital. They consulted an out-of-hours GP, who agreed.
The paramedics relayed their assessment to Paul O’Flaherty, the prison’s security manager. He refused to allow the transfer, saying Mr Glass would not go to hospital unless he was dying. The ambulance crew left at around 10pm. Mr O’Flaherty decided prison officers would monitor Mr Glass by visiting his cell door, rousing him and checking that he responded.
A second ambulance crew attended at 4:22am on 15 May, after another call at 2:44am. They found Mr Glass in an “unremarkable condition” and left without taking him to hospital. At approximately 7:20am, officers found him apparently unresponsive and began CPR. Ambulance crews returned, but resuscitation attempts failed. Mr Glass was pronounced dead at 8:15am.
Sheriff More found that ambulance service staff had not been adequately trained on who was responsible for deciding whether a prisoner should be taken to hospital. The paramedic who consulted the prison manager believed he had a guardian-like role and could refuse consent for the transfer. The inquiry also found that the prison manager’s decision to rely on officers’ observations was inappropriate and not based on Scottish Prison Service guidance or training.
An ambulance service review after the death found that staff uncertainty about prisoners’ healthcare rights and the perceived authority of prison staff had influenced the initial decision. It recommended joint guidance with the prison service. Sheriff More said such guidance had since been developed and addressed the training deficiencies identified in the inquiry.
The sheriff made no recommendations.



