Police deaths watchdog warns rising caseload is delaying investigations
Scotland’s Police Investigations and Review Commissioner (PIRC) is handling a record number of investigations into deaths involving police, with the rising caseload delaying some inquiries, its commissioner, Laura Paton, has said.
PIRC is currently managing 191 investigations, including 49 deaths. It opened 41 death investigations in the year to 31 March 2026, up 128 per cent from 18 the previous year. Seven concerned domestic abuse-related homicides and suicides.
Ms Paton said the organisation’s demand exceeded its resources and warned that delays would worsen without reduced demand or additional funding.
“We are experiencing a sustained increase in demand that exceeds our available resources and is beyond our control.
“We will take all reasonable steps to work efficiently, prioritise serious investigations, and maintain the quality of those investigations, however there is a limit to what we alone can achieve.
“In the absence of external intervention – such as a reduction in demand, additional funding or the delayed expansion of our statutory functions - a further deterioration in the timeliness of our investigations is inevitable.
“This means that we will not be able to deliver the service that the public rightly expects; this will affect bereaved families and complainers, as well as confidence in police accountability and policing itself.”
PIRC received 745 referrals in 2025-26 and took 185 forward for full investigation. The Crown Office instructed 175, while PIRC chose to investigate 10 itself. The commissioner said this left less capacity for discretionary inquiries.
The watchdog met its target to complete 80 per cent of its most serious investigations within 90 days, but performance fell from 100 per cent in 2024-25 to 83 per cent in 2025-26. It completed 71 per cent of other category B and C investigations within 120 days, below its 80 per cent target.
PIRC also expects more people to seek reviews of police complaint handling as Police Scotland works through a backlog. Applications for reviews rose 29 per cent in the reporting year, covering 965 allegations. PIRC met its targets for processing those applications.
New legislation will expand the commissioner’s powers and duties. Ms Paton said PIRC was discussing additional resources with the Scottish government to support the new responsibilities.



