Brittany Thomas: When becoming a family is only part of the journey
Brittany Thomas
Adoption Week Scotland (16-20 November) is an opportunity to celebrate adoptive families, but also to recognise that the legal journey towards an adoption order is not always as straightforward as families might hope it will be. Wright, Johnston & Mackenzie (WJM) LLP family lawyer, Brittany Thomas, reflects on a recent adoption that she worked on where this was the case, and on the importance of giving clear advice and support throughout the process.
For many families, by the time an application for an adoption order reaches court, the most important part has already happened – the child has been placed with them and is living as part of their family unit. In addition, relationships have been formed, routines established and, in every meaningful day-to-day sense, they are already a family.
The adoption order provides something different to that – permanence and recognition in a legal sense. It is perhaps therefore understandable that adopters can approach the court process expecting the final legal stage to be relatively straightforward.
Sometimes it is. Sometimes it isn’t. What I have been reminded of through a recent case is that even an adoption which is not opposed, and should be very straightforward, can still take considerably longer than anyone initially anticipates it to.
I recently acted in an adoption application, which on its face, ought to have progressed relatively smoothly. Instead, the proceedings lasted for more than a year and required a number of court hearings before the adoption order was ultimately made.
There were several reasons for the delay. One was the time taken for the necessary Section 17 Report to be prepared. Under the Adoption and Children (Scotland) Act 2007, where a child has been placed for adoption by an adoption agency, that agency is required to provide the court with a report addressing amongst other things, the suitability of the prospective adopters and matters relative to the child’s welfare. A case can’t proceed without it, and therefore clients are very often at the mercy of the report writer.
There were also difficulties surrounding service of the adoption petition on the child’s birth parents. None of those issues ultimately prevented the adoption from being granted.
However, it did mean repeated hearings, periods of waiting and significant uncertainty for the Petitioner. As the solicitor, it is easy to look at these stages just as procedural matters which simply have to be worked through. But, for the person waiting for the adoption order to be granted in order to make them a legal parent of their child, this can feel very different.
Explaining what is happening particularly when nothing appears to be happening is very important. That recent experience reinforced to me that one of the most important things we can do when advising adopters is to be realistic about the process from the beginning.
Adoption proceedings can take time. This does not necessarily mean there is a difficulty with the application or that the court has concerns about whether or not an adoption order should be made.
Reports have to be obtained, individuals may require to be formally notified, and it may be difficult to trace them because of a transient lifestyle or if they have moved abroad.
The court may also require matters to be clarified or brought back before them at another hearing. Some of those steps are outside the control of both the adopter and their solicitor. That means that communication is of the upmost importance.
When a case appears to have stalled, I think the solicitor’s role extends beyond simply telling a client that they are still waiting. It is explaining what we are waiting for, why it is required, what steps are being taken to move matters forward and what is likely to happen next and when.
Where appropriate, it also means actively chasing outstanding reports and procedural steps and ensuring that avoidable delay is kept to a minimum. Perhaps most importantly, it means helping the client distinguish between a procedural delay and a substantive problem with their application.
Another court hearing can sound alarming to somebody who has never been involved in the court process before. Explaining that the hearing is required to resolve a procedural issue, rather than because of their ability to adopt the child is being questioned, can make an enormous difference during an already emotional process.
In most, if not all adoption cases, the family relationship already exists long before the final order is granted by the courts. The child is being cared for, loved and included in family life already. What the adopter is waiting for is for the law to formally recognise and secure that relationship. When that recognition takes longer than expected the waiting can be difficult.
Solicitors cannot promise prospective adopters that the process will be quick. Nor can solicitors control every part of the adoption procedure. What we can do is make sure that clients understand the process that they are entering, that we are candid with them about timescales and difficulties as they arise, that we pursue outstanding steps wherever we can and that, throughout the process, they know what is happening and why.
For me, that is possibly the most important part of acting in adoption proceedings. The adoption order may be the legal conclusion to the case, but for the family involved it represents something much more personal. It is the law finally recognising the family life they may already may have been living for years.
Brittany Thomas is a solicitor at WJM



