Sheriff Appeal Court upholds £750 award to disabled SNP member over failure to make reasonable adjustments
The Sheriff Appeal Court has refused an appeal by a Scottish National Party member who sought a higher damages award after a sheriff found that the party had discriminated against her by failing to make reasonable adjustments for her hearing disability.
Barbara Ann Grigor had been awarded £750 after the sheriff found that the SNP should have provided her with a written summary of discussions at a local branch meeting which she was unable to attend because of her disability. Sheriff Principal N A Ross held that the sheriff had been entitled to assess the party’s culpability at the lower end of the scale and rejected Ms Grigor’s argument that she should have received the £5,000 maximum sought in her simple procedure claim.
The opinion of the court was delivered by Sheriff Principal Ross.
Written information not provided
Ms Grigor, who is a member of the SNP, has a hearing disability which prevents her from conversing in noisy environments or participating in telephone or video calls and means that she cannot attend group meetings. Her disability is not assisted by a hearing loop. The dispute arose following a meeting of the party’s Coatbridge and Chryston branch on 20 June 2025 which Ms Grigor did not attend. After reading the minutes she emailed the branch secretary seeking fuller information about matters which had been discussed.
The secretary explained who had attended, provided an overview of certain events and told her that the minutes were not intended to provide a verbatim account. Ms Grigor responded that this did not answer her request because she wanted the substance of what had been discussed. The secretary offered to put her in contact with a councillor for a fuller update. Ms Grigor reminded the secretary of her disability and indicated that she intended to make a formal complaint of discrimination based on the party’s failure to provide full written details.
She subsequently complained to the SNP’s administration. Its national secretary asked whether she was seeking fuller minutes, but Ms Grigor responded that she had already made a formal complaint and required it to be resolved. After further correspondence she was told that consideration was being given to what adjustments could be made. About a month later, with no further substantive response, she intimated that proceedings would be raised.
The sheriff conducted the proceedings through written submissions as an adjustment for Ms Grigor’s disability. He found that she was disabled within the meaning of the Equality Act 2010, that the SNP owed her a duty to make reasonable adjustments and that her requests for information had been reasonable. The party had failed to explain why the requested information was not provided, and the sheriff found on the balance of probabilities that it had breached its duty and thereby discriminated against Ms Grigor. Providing a written summary of the meeting would have constituted a reasonable adjustment.
However, the discrimination was not found to be wilful or malicious. The sheriff considered that the initial problem arose because the branch secretary had not fully understood what Ms Grigor wanted. By the time the matter reached the national secretary, Ms Grigor’s patience had run out and she declined to engage further with efforts to clarify the remedy she sought. He therefore assessed the SNP’s culpability at the lower end of the scale and awarded £750.
Sheriff misled by altered email
Ms Grigor appealed on three grounds. She argued that the sheriff had misunderstood written evidence she lodged, had wrongly concluded that she had failed to justify the £5,000 sought and had erred in finding that she had withdrawn her cooperation before the matter could be resolved.
A central issue concerned an email dated 13 August 2025 which Ms Grigor had lodged in evidence. At the bottom of the document appeared the words “NO FURTHER RESPONSES”. The sheriff understood those words to have formed part of the email when it was originally sent and treated them as indicating that Ms Grigor did not wish to correspond further with the party.
On appeal, Ms Grigor explained that she had added the phrase to her copy of the email afterwards and that it had not appeared in the communication received by the SNP. Sheriff Principal Ross held that the resulting misunderstanding was not an appealable error by the sheriff. He said: “This confusion was entirely of the appellant’s making. She lodged the email in an altered condition.” The sheriff had reached a logical conclusion from the evidence which Ms Grigor herself had lodged and had not made a finding which was plainly wrong.
Sheriff Principal Ross added: “The sheriff did not misdirect himself. He was misdirected by the appellant. No remedy is available at appeal.” Even considering the evidence on the corrected factual basis, the court held that Ms Grigor would not have established victimisation under section 27 of the Equality Act. The sheriff had suggested in his appeal report that, had he understood the email correctly, he might have found victimisation on the basis that the SNP had failed to respond adequately after Ms Grigor alleged discrimination.
However, Sheriff Principal Ross held that it was not sufficient merely to show that Ms Grigor had subsequently been ignored. There also had to be evidence of a causal connection between the allegation of discrimination and the alleged detriment. No such connection had been proved. The correspondence instead showed various attempts by the SNP to address her complaint.
The court concluded that the more likely explanation for the cessation of correspondence was that Ms Grigor had expressly intimated that she was proceeding to court.
Vento bands not binding
Ms Grigor also challenged the level of damages, arguing that £750 was inadequate. She relied on the Vento v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police bands commonly used by employment tribunals to assess awards for injury to feelings in discrimination cases. The lowest band for 2026 began at £1,200.
Sheriff Principal Ross held that the sheriff was not bound to apply the Vento bands, although they could be used as guidance. The court noted that those bands focused on matters including the seriousness, duration and impact of discriminatory conduct but did not account for all possible mitigating or limiting factors. In the present case, the sheriff had been entitled to take account of Ms Grigor’s own conduct insofar as it reduced the opportunity for the SNP to remedy its earlier failure.
The award of £750 was therefore within the range reasonably open to him and was not plainly wrong. The court also rejected Ms Grigor’s contention that asking for the maximum £5,000 available in her claim was sufficient to justify an award at that level.
Sheriff Principal Ross observed that “the existence of a maximum sum” did not mean that the maximum was the starting point. The sheriff had been required to assess an appropriate award on the circumstances and had given reasons for his conclusion. The original finding that the SNP failed to make a reasonable adjustment was not challenged in the appeal. The dispute before the Sheriff Appeal Court concerned the sheriff’s treatment of the evidence, the absence of a victimisation finding and the amount of compensation.
The appeal was refused. The court made no immediate order on expenses, allowing either party 14 days to make submissions, failing which there would be no liability for expenses on either side.



