Criminal Justice Committee seeks funding boost to avert police job losses

Criminal Justice Committee seeks funding boost to avert police job losses

The Criminal Justice Committee is calling on the Scottish government to provide a significant funding uplift for justice sector services for 2027-28, as part of its pre-budget report.

The committee warns that a flat-cash settlement for Police Scotland would mean an £80m deficit and result in the loss of over 1,200 officer and civilian staff posts in the next financial year. It said an urgent funding uplift is essential to address unavoidable cost pressures across the service, address critical estate backlogs and avoid deep cuts to officer  and civilian staff numbers.

The committee said the Scottish government should provide dedicated capital funding for Police Scotland to address critical estate backlogs, specifically the modernisation of custody suites, alongside sustained capital investment for fleet replacement and the full rollout of body-worn video and digital evidence tools. 

To tackle the huge demand placed on police officers attending mental health call-outs, the committee wants to see the Scottish government introduce a binding inter-portfolio agreement between Justice and Health which would ensure mental health and social care professionals respond to non-criminal mental health and welfare calls, rather than police officers. Currently, officers are losing 750,000 hours a year to non-criminal mental health call-outs.

On the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS), the committee called for an increase in capital funding to address long overdue repairs and upgrades to the SFRS estate which now exceed £800 million. The committee says this funding should go towards the installation of modern decontamination facilities across all fire stations, RAAC remediation and modernisation of the service fleet.

The committee also recommends that SFRS receive targeted resource support to reform the Retained Duty System (RDS), to reduce the current 31 per cent RDS vacancy rate, which can mean up to 200 of Scotland’s 345 on-call appliances are unavailable on a given day.

The committee also took evidence on the issue of prison reform, with Scotland’s prisons reaching record population numbers of 8,603, and operating at 109 per cent capacity. The committee is urging the Scottish government to publish a fully costed, long term prison capacity strategy which should include a clear decision and implementation timetable regarding the future of HMP Barlinnie. It has also called for more funding for community-based alternatives, justice social work and electronic GPS monitoring.

Issues caused by short-term funding grants for third sector organisations are highlighted by the committee, which wants to see the Scottish government transition all third-sector community justice, diversion and throughcare funding from 12-month grants to three-to-five-year settlements starting in the next financial year. It also recommends multi-year, inflation-indexed core funding for specialist victim support services (such as Rape Crisis Scotland and Victim Support Scotland) to help avoid specialist sexual violence services run closed waiting lists.

Criminal Justice committee convener, David Linden, said: “Overcrowded prisons, crumbling stations and the threat of over 1,200 lost police posts show a justice system stretched to breaking point.

“We understand the tough financial backdrop, but Ministers cannot hide behind operational independence when budget choices leave frontline services unable to cope. Protecting public safety requires properly resourcing the services that deliver it.

“Year-to-year crisis management is no longer tenable. The Scottish government must develop and publish a multi-year justice investment strategy, which sets the sector on a sustainable path, reduces pressure on services and moves towards a model of prevention, early intervention, community-based justice and rehabilitation.

“Thanks to all the organisations and individuals who submitted evidence to support our committee’s scrutiny.”  

Join more than 17,300 legal professionals in receiving our FREE daily email newsletter
Share icon
Share this article: