Outer House rules Aberdeen restaurant insurer entitled to reject fire claim over unattended grill

Outer House rules Aberdeen restaurant insurer entitled to reject fire claim over unattended grill

The Outer House has held that an insurer was entitled to refuse cover for a fire which caused extensive damage to an Aberdeen restaurant after finding that a solid-fuel grill had been left unattended in breach of a condition precedent in the policy.

Lord Lake granted decree of absolvitor in favour of Intact Insurance UK Ltd, formerly Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Ltd, after concluding that P B Development Company Ltd had failed to comply with a kitchen equipment condition requiring cooking equipment not to be left unattended while its heat source was operating. The court also held that section 11 of the Insurance Act 2015 did not prevent the insurer relying on the breach, as the restaurant company had not shown that leaving the grill unattended could not have increased the risk of the fire which occurred.

Murray KC, instructed by Ledingham Chalmers LLP, appeared for the pursuer. The Dean of Faculty KC and Breen, instructed by DAC Beachcroft Claims Scotland LLP, appeared for the defender.

Fire at Vovem

P B Development owned and operated Vovem Meat & Liquor in Aberdeen. It entered into a contract of insurance with Intact in March 2024 which included cover against fire. On 26 September 2024 a fire caused extensive damage to the restaurant. It arose in connection with an “ox grill”, a stainless-steel appliance which burned wood and charcoal to chargrill food. Above it was an extraction system consisting of a canopy, filters and ductwork.

P B Development made a claim under its policy. Intact denied liability on the basis that the insured had failed to comply with the Kitchen Equipment clause. That provision required, among other things, that “all cooking equipment is not left unattended whilst the heat source is operating”. It also stated in bold that failure to comply with any of the listed requirements would result in the insurer not paying a property damage or business interruption claim.

The proof, with quantum reserved, raised whether the clause was a condition precedent to liability, whether it had been breached, and whether section 11 of the 2015 Act prevented Intact relying on the breach. P B Development argued that the clause should not be treated as a condition precedent merely because of its wording. It submitted that a commercially sensible interpretation was required and that aspects of the provision were vague, potentially unworkable and insufficiently responsive to risk.

Lord Lake rejected that approach. He held that the words used were clear and that a reasonable person reading the policy would understand compliance to be necessary if a claim was to be paid. The fact that the clause was not expressly labelled a “condition precedent” was not decisive. Nor did asserted vagueness prevent it having that status where the contractual consequence of non-compliance was clear.

Left unattended

The next issue was what “not left unattended” meant and whether the grill had in fact been unattended before the fire. Lord Lake rejected expert evidence insofar as it sought to define the contractual term. Interpretation was a matter of law and the expert’s view could not determine the meaning of the policy. The judge considered earlier authorities involving unattended property and held that the purpose of the clause was plainly to reduce the risk of fire. It was intended to ensure that someone remained aware of what was happening and was in a position to intervene to prevent or minimise damage.

Attendance did not require a person to stand directly in front of the grill and give it constant attention. But it was not enough that somebody was simply nearby. A person had to be in a position to “look after or tend to” the grill. CCTV footage allowed the court to reconstruct events in the kitchen. Staff lit the grill shortly after 11am and tended it intermittently while carrying out other preparation work. At various stages employees walked past or looked towards it. One chef, Ross Keith, was involved with the grill periodically but also worked elsewhere and at one point left the kitchen for approximately two minutes and 45 seconds.

The footage later showed burning drops of fat falling from the canopy. Staff returned to the grill and attempted to extinguish flames before becoming aware that fire had spread elsewhere in the building. Lord Lake held that there were periods before discovery of the fire when nobody was in a position to tend the grill. The presence of other employees in the kitchen or restaurant did not itself amount to attendance.

He therefore concluded that the grill had been left unattended and that the condition precedent had not been complied with.

Section 11 did not save claim

P B Development relied on section 11 of the Insurance Act 2015, which prevents an insurer relying on non-compliance with certain risk-reducing terms where the insured shows that the non-compliance “could not have increased the risk of the loss which actually occurred in the circumstances in which it occurred”.

The company argued that the absence of a person attending the grill had not increased the risk of this fire. Staff evidence was that visible flames were not unusual and would not necessarily have prompted intervention. It also contended that the fire originated in concealed ducting and would not have been visible to anyone watching the grill.

Lord Lake noted that there was little authority on section 11(3). He explained that the provision could apply where a term reduces a particular risk generally but the actual loss occurs through a mechanism unrelated to the breach. He gave the example of a policy requiring secure locks to reduce the risk of intruders entering a building and starting a fire. If the locks were inadequate but a fire instead resulted from faulty electrical wiring, the breach relating to locks could not have increased the risk of the fire which occurred.

The present case was different. The insured risk was fire and the mechanism by which it occurred was the spread of heat or flame from the grill’s fuel bed. The unattended-grill condition was directed both at the type of loss and the mechanism by which it arose. The fire experts agreed that grease deposits in the extraction ducting had ignited, although they differed on how ignition occurred.

Lord Lake preferred the evidence supporting the insurer’s case that the fire had first taken hold beneath the canopy before spreading into the ductwork. He noted evidence that staff had sprayed water at flames around the canopy and that there had been a similar near-miss the previous day. Had somebody been attending the grill and observed the fire earlier, it was likely that action would have been taken which might have prevented it spreading into the duct.

P B Development had therefore failed to establish that leaving the grill unattended could not have increased the risk of the loss. Section 11 did not prevent Intact from relying on the breach. Having reached that conclusion, Lord Lake sustained Intact’s second, third and fourth pleas-in-law, repelled the pursuer’s pleas and granted decree of absolvitor.

Join more than 17,300 legal professionals in receiving our FREE daily email newsletter
Share icon
Share this article: