Outer House awards £380,000 to motorcyclist injured in Scottish Six Days Trial collision
The Outer House has awarded £380,000 to an experienced motorcyclist who was seriously injured after colliding with a travelling marshal riding in the opposite direction during the 2022 Scottish Six Days Trial.
About this case:
- Citation:[2026] CSOH 111
- Judgment:
- Court:Court of Session Outer House
- Judge:Lady Drummond
Lady Drummond held that Edinburgh and District Motor Club Ltd had negligently failed to identify and control the risk created by allowing travelling marshals to ride against the flow of competitors on forestry tracks. However, pursuer Mark Lamplough was found one-third contributorily negligent because he had been travelling above the 15mph speed limit.
The court assessed total damages at £570,000, including £70,000 for loss connected with a motorcycle-tour business which had not yet begun full trading, before reducing the award to £380,000 for contributory negligence.
Brodie KC and Markie, advocate, instructed by Thompsons LLP, appeared for the pursuer. Smith KC and Black, advocate, instructed by Clyde & Co LLP, appeared for the defenders.
Travelling marshals
Mr Lamplough was taking part in the Scottish Six Days Trial near Fort William on 2 May 2022. The event, which has been run for more than 100 years, involved around 280 competitors riding a marked route of approximately 90 miles each day, including technically demanding observed sections linked by roads and forestry tracks. A 15mph speed limit applied on forestry ground. Travelling marshals patrolled the tracks to monitor competitors’ speed and protect members of the public using the forest.
Mr Lamplough, an experienced motorcyclist who had previously competed in the Trial 24 times, was riding along a forestry track in Leanachan Forest when he approached a right-hand bend. He was following a worn riding line on the inside of the bend, where an embankment restricted visibility. He collided with marshal Bruce Johnston, who was travelling in the opposite direction. Mr Lamplough maintained that he had been travelling at around 15mph and had only seconds to react when he saw the marshal. Mr Johnston said the pursuer was travelling well above the limit and was not looking where he was going.
Lady Drummond accepted that both riders had very limited time to react. She rejected Mr Johnston’s evidence that he had slowed to five or six mph and was virtually stationary at impact, instead finding that he and another marshal had been travelling at least 15mph. The judge also rejected the allegation that Mr Lamplough had been looking down rather than where he was going. However, on the evidence as a whole, including the distance he travelled after impact, she found on the balance of probabilities that he had been travelling above the 15mph limit, although it was impossible to determine by how much.
The club argued that travelling marshals had operated in both directions for years without a previous collision and that competitors had been warned that marshals would be present. Mr Lamplough relied on evidence from risk-management expert Dr Laurence Ball, who criticised the event’s risk assessment. Although it identified collisions on forest roads as a hazard, it did not specifically address the danger created by marshals riding motorcycles towards competitors on the same tracks. Dr Ball also identified possible controls, including unidirectional travel, express warnings about opposing marshals, a keep-left system, lower speeds for marshals travelling against the flow and instructions to take bends on a wider line to improve visibility.
Obvious and foreseeable risk
Lady Drummond held that organisers of the Trial were required to take reasonable care to identify material hazards, assess the level of risk, identify reasonable mitigation measures and inform participants of the assessment clearly. She distinguished hazards inherent in an off-road event from the risk in the present case. Travelling marshals had been introduced onto the course by the organisers and were therefore not an inherent feature of the terrain.
The defenders’ risk assessment failed properly to consider competitor safety or the possibility of collision between competitors and marshals travelling in opposite directions. Although participants had been told that travelling marshals would be present, Lady Drummond said there was “a significant omission” in failing to warn that marshals could be travelling towards them, particularly when competitors themselves were required to travel in one direction and could be disqualified for going the opposite way.
She said the introduction of travelling marshals riding against the flow of around 280 competitors created “an obvious and reasonably foreseeable risk of collision”. The fact that the system had operated for nine years without an accident did not make the risk unforeseeable. It merely showed that the risk had not previously materialised.
Lady Drummond also found Mr Johnston negligent. He knew competitors would be approaching, was familiar with the worn riding line and had not seen a competitor for several minutes. He should therefore have approached the bend more cautiously and positioned himself to maximise his visibility.
The court held that both the organisers’ failures and Mr Johnston’s conduct caused the accident. Measures such as explicit warnings, a keep-left rule or instructions that marshals travelling against the flow should approach bends more slowly and from positions offering better visibility could have prevented the collision. High-visibility clothing, headlights and reliance on experienced marshals exercising common sense were not sufficient controls.
One-third contributory negligence
The court nevertheless held that Mr Lamplough had failed to take reasonable care for his own safety by exceeding the speed limit. Lady Drummond accepted that he could not reasonably have expected to encounter a motorcycle marshal travelling towards him. However, he knew that the forestry tracks remained open to members of the public and was required to ride at a speed appropriate to the limited visibility around the bend.
She was not satisfied that compliance with the 15mph limit would necessarily have prevented the collision, given the marshals’ position and restricted sightlines, but found that a lower speed would probably have reduced its severity. The club’s blameworthiness was greater. It had introduced the hazard without adequately assessing or controlling it, while Mr Johnston knew that oncoming competitors were likely and failed to position himself appropriately.
Lady Drummond therefore apportioned one-third of the responsibility to Mr Lamplough. The parties had agreed damages of £500,000, inclusive of interest, subject to liability. A separate dispute concerned loss associated with Mr Lamplough’s company, Your Adventure Life Ltd, which he had intended to operate as a motorcycle-tour business.
The company had not begun full trading before the accident, although it had been established, marketed and had secured bookings for a European tour which was cancelled because of the pandemic. Lady Drummond accepted that there were “considerable uncertainties” over the business and rejected a conventional multiplier approach. However, she was satisfied that, but for the accident, Mr Lamplough would have continued taking bookings and that the company would probably have made some profit.
She awarded £70,000 for that loss. Total damages were therefore £570,000, reduced by one third to reflect contributory negligence, leaving an award of £380,000 with interest at eight per cent from 22 July 2026.



