High Court refuses Lithuanian national leave to appeal extradition order over prison conditions and gang threats
The High Court of Justiciary has refused a Lithuanian national leave to appeal against an order for his extradition to face bribery charges, rejecting arguments based on prison conditions, threats from an organised crime group, ill health and interference with his private and family life.
About this case:
- Citation:[2026] HCJAC 48
- Judgment:
- Court:Appeal Court of the High Court of Justiciary
- Judge:Lord Matthews
Lord Matthews, delivering the opinion of the court, held that the sheriff had been entitled to rely on assurances from the Lithuanian prison service and that the evidence did not establish a real risk of treatment contrary to Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
The appellant, identified as AB, had also failed to show exceptional circumstances capable of overcoming his fugitive status for the purposes of a passage-of-time objection.
The appellant appeared as a party. McKenzie (sol adv), instructed by the Crown Agent, appeared for the Lord Advocate representing the Republic of Lithuania. The opinion of the court was delivered by Lord Matthews, sitting with Lady Wise and Lady Carmichael.
Extradition ordered
The appellant, a Lithuanian national, was ordered to be extradited by a sheriff at Edinburgh on 26 March 2026 pursuant to a European Arrest Warrant issued in June 2016. He had appeared in Lithuania on bribery charges and pleaded not guilty. His case was adjourned for four months and he was released subject to a requirement to report to a police station every two weeks and not leave the country.
Following the death of his father, he travelled to the United Kingdom for the funeral and remained here. He did not notify the Lithuanian authorities that he was living in the UK. Before the sheriff, he resisted extradition on three grounds. He argued that removal would disproportionately interfere with his Article 8 rights; that detention in Lithuania would expose him to treatment contrary to Article 3 because of prison conditions and threats from people to whom he owed money; and that extradition was barred by the passage of time under section 14 of the Extradition Act 2003.
The sheriff heard evidence from the appellant, his nephew and George Tugushi, an expert on Lithuanian prison conditions. The appellant said he had lived in Scotland for eight or nine years and had settled status. His five children were in Lithuania, although one son had previously lived with him in Glasgow. He also had relatives in Scotland and elsewhere in the UK. He maintained that he had borrowed money from a criminal gang in Lithuania and that a debt which began at £5,000 had increased to £70,000. His nephew said he had received threatening calls and messages and had made payments towards the debt.
Mr Tugushi referred to concerns about Lithuanian prison conditions, including inadequate healthcare, poor facilities and inter-prisoner violence linked to informal prisoner hierarchies. However, he had last visited a Lithuanian prison in 2018 and could not comment on the specific risk to the appellant. The sheriff did not find the appellant credible or reliable, identifying inconsistencies between his evidence and that of his nephew. Nevertheless, he was prepared to assume that the threat from the criminal group was genuine.
He concluded that the appellant had limited close family connections in Scotland and that extradition would cause little interference with his private or family life when weighed against the public interest in honouring extradition obligations. The sheriff also held that the appellant was a fugitive. The passage of time was substantial, but there was no credible evidence that extradition would be unjust or oppressive.
Specific assurances
On Article 3, the sheriff accepted that violence existed within the Lithuanian prison system but was not satisfied that the appellant faced a real risk of prohibited ill-treatment. He treated Mr Tugushi’s evidence with caution because it was not specific to the appellant and was not fully current. The sheriff also relied on assurances from the Lithuanian prison service concerning accommodation, assessment of vulnerability, protection and conditions for prisoners placed in isolation for their safety.
On appeal, AB advanced seven grounds, including alleged breaches of Articles 2, 3, 6 and 8, his medical condition, passage of time, difficulties with interpretation and alleged deficiencies in his previous legal representation. The High Court considered further assurances supplied by the Lithuanian authorities. These stated that AB would initially be detained at Kaunas prison and that, if sentenced, decisions about his placement would take account of risk, public safety, health, medical needs and any information indicating that he should not be held with particular prisoners.
The court held that the sheriff’s findings on the alleged gang threat and prison conditions had been open to him. Lord Matthews said that, having regard to the evidence and assurances, “it cannot be maintained that the sheriff erred in holding that there was no real risk of a breach of the appellant’s rights”.
The court also considered reports about systemic problems in Lithuanian prisons. A 2024 report from the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture recorded positive developments, including a reduction in the prison population and improved addiction treatment, but continued to express serious concern about informal prisoner hierarchies, organised crime and widespread inter-prisoner violence.
The court nevertheless held that the specific protective measures described in the assurances were sufficient to answer the risk advanced in AB’s case. The appellant’s medical ground was also rejected. He had not led evidence before the sheriff that he suffered from serious cardiac or neurological illness. The High Court allowed him to lodge medical records at the appeal hearing. Those disclosed repeated complaints including chest, back and ankle pain and skin problems, but no diagnosis of heart disease or neurological illness.
The court described the records as showing “a history of various aches, pains and complaints but no diagnosis of any particular illness”. There was insufficient evidence to establish the ground, and the ordinary presumption that appropriate medical treatment would be available in the requesting state had not been rebutted.
Fugitive status decisive on delay
AB also argued that his right to a fair trial under Article 6 had been compromised because he spoke Russian rather than Lithuanian and had been provided with unsuitable interpreters.
The court noted that the point had not been raised before the sheriff, where AB had been represented and had given evidence through an interpreter without any apparent difficulty. His own medical records also recorded him stating that he was fluent in both Russian and Lithuanian. The argument came “far too late” and was not well founded.
The passage-of-time ground was similarly rejected. The court considered it clear that AB was a fugitive and that no exceptional circumstances had been demonstrated. His departure from Lithuania occurred while criminal proceedings remained active and while he was subject to reporting requirements and a prohibition on leaving the country. The court described the point as “unarguable”.
His Article 8 case also failed. The court held that, on the evidence accepted by the sheriff, it was “quite impossible” to maintain that extradition would disproportionately interfere with his private and family life. Finally, AB alleged that his former legal representatives had failed to deal adequately with the interpreter issue and to prepare his defence.
The High Court found no specific or detailed criticism capable of establishing defective representation. The ground was so lacking in specification that the court regarded it as irrelevant. The court concluded that none of the seven grounds had merit and refused leave to appeal, leaving the sheriff’s extradition order in place.



