ECtHR bars Romanian lawyer for two years over AI-generated citations

ECtHR bars Romanian lawyer for two years over AI-generated citations

The European Court of Human Rights has barred a Romanian lawyer for two years after finding that her legal submissions, prepared with AI, contained repeated errors and fabricated case citations.

A chamber found that her submissions cited non-existent cases, invented paragraphs in genuine judgments and decisions, and used relevant case law inaccurately or in ways that contradicted her arguments.

The lawyer acknowledged using AI tools to draft the submissions and described the mistakes as “inaccuracies” and “citation errors”. The chamber concluded they were a repeated pattern of substantive errors, rather than isolated mistakes.

It said lawyers must check AI-generated legal references and arguments against authoritative sources, such as the court’s HUDOC database. The lawyer admitted she had not checked all the citations sufficiently; the chamber found that some had not been checked at all.

The errors required the court to spend considerable time verifying the submissions and handling proceedings over the lawyer’s conduct, which the chamber said had prejudiced the administration of justice.

The chamber proposed a two-year exclusion, which the court’s president approved on 13 November under Rule 44D of the court’s rules. The decision applies only to the lawyer, not the second representative in the case. The court said her right to represent applicants could be restored under the rules.

Join more than 17,300 legal professionals in receiving our FREE daily email newsletter
Share icon
Share this article: