Call for MoJ to establish ‘NHS 111’-style national legal service to improve access to justice
The Ministry of Justice should establish a national legal service to improve people’s access to justice and address unmet legal need, Westminster’s Justice Committee has said.
In its report Access to Justice: Access to Legal Services published today, the cross-party committee chaired by Labour MP Catherine Atkinson called for a national legal service “which treats reducing unmet legal need as a cross-government responsibility and establishes a permanent programme of work with sufficient authority, expertise and resources to coordinate delivery”.
The national legal service’s three core functions should be to:
- provide people with reliable legal information and identify which support is appropriate for them, analogous to NHS 111
- signpost between different services while measuring their demand and capacity
- identify shortfalls in provision and directing resources to addressing them
MPs warned that despite legal problems being widespread, the government ‘does not have a sufficient, geographically detailed understanding of legal need’. The legal advice sector, the report found, is sustained by a patchwork of legal aid, local authority commissioning, charitable grants, pro bono work and short-term government programmes.
A national legal service, the report said, should combine a clear national identity and set of expectations with services delivered locally through different organisations. It would measure their demand and capacity and identify shortfalls in provision and direct resources towards addressing them. It would also be a permanent mechanism with sufficient authority, expertise and resources to coordinate activity across government and ensure accountability for results, MPs added. Digital services should be a key element and the government should create a coherent digital gateway, consistent signposting, and a kitemark for trusted information. It should also invest in an independently evaluated AI-assisted legal support platform integrated with existing services and routes to human assistance.
MPs set out opportunities for where the government could find and raise additional revenue through a ‘portfolio’ of funding mechanisms and strictly ring-fence that revenue for reducing unmet legal need. Supplementary income cannot compensate for an inadequate core settlement for legal aid, courts or other justice services, the report said. Potential sources could include an independently administered Interest on Lawyers’ Client Accounts scheme, dormant client balances, undistributed collective action sums, recovered criminal assets and carefully targeted contributions from litigation funding profits and high-value litigation.
The report raised concerns that consumers cannot easily establish whether a provider is regulated, what protections regulation gives or where to seek redress. Recent firm failures, it noted, have also exposed serious weaknesses in supervision and damaged consumer confidence. MPs recommended there must be greater emphasis on regulated activities and risks, clearer consumer information and redress, and effective oversight of new digital and AI-assisted services.
Such change, the report recommended, should include an extension of qualified one-way costs shifting, a review of fixed recoverable costs, immediate legislation to reverse the effects of the PACCAR judgment, statutory regulation of third-party litigation funding and protection of opt-out collective actions. Third-party litigation funding is vital for enabling access to justice, and the market has grown more than tenfold since 2011. It requires proportionate and effective regulation, the report said.
Chair of the Justice Committee and Labour MP, Catherine Atkinson, said: “Demand for legal help is rising, yet advice services are shrinking and where you live can determine what help you can get. We recognise the value of getting help early in the NHS. The same principle applies to justice. Early legal advice can help people resolve problems before they reach a court or tribunal, saving them time, money and stress.
“The Justice Committee is calling for a National Legal Service. Modelled on NHS 111, it would give people across England and Wales somewhere to turn when they first have a legal problem, so they can understand their rights and find the right help.
“Such a permanent mechanism is essential for understanding legal need, coordinating activity across departments, monitoring service capacity and providing greater coherence.
“For too long, legal advice has been provided through a disjointed system, with responsibility spread across government departments, councils, charities and regulators. The Ministry of Justice should take the lead in coordinating services, checking whether they can meet demand and acting where people are going without help.
“Legal rights are meaningful only where people can recognise them, obtain reliable assistance and secure an effective remedy. The MoJ must treat access to justice as a core purpose, not as a collection of disconnected programmes.”


